Thankfully for Rogue, she's not the first person he's run into from this party who seems to be from some point in his relative future. He's already gotten into it with John, and although Laura didn't seem to know who Hank was, she was also a mutant, so at this point it's pretty clear that the fae are just starting their own mutant collection.

"Let me guess," he says in something of a deadpan tone, "you were expecting me to be a little more... blue?"